Yzabel / August 12, 2012

Angel Evolution by David Estes

My rating: [rating=3]

Summary:

When Taylor meets Gabriel at college, she is in awe of the subtle glow that surrounds him. No one else, not even her best friend, seems to notice.

Something about him scares her.

Is all as it appears? While Taylor struggles for answers, she finds herself in the middle of a century old war centered on one miraculous revelation: evolution.

Review:

I had had this novel on my radar for some time, and finally got to read it in July (although I hadn’t posted my review yet). I must say it made me spend a good moment, even though it has its flaws.

I think the major problem for me as a reader was that I found connecting with the characters a little hard. Especially the main female character, Taylor, who remained quite bland for a good deal of the story, until she finally grew something of a spine. Besides, she accepted Gabriel’s story so quickly! It would’ve been more believable if she had been more of a skeptic, asked more questions, be warier of him, kept a distance at first… not fall into his arms so soon. I didn’t know where to stand regarding Gabriel either, couldn’t decide if he was suffering from chronic lying disorder, or was just brainwashed, or tried to convince himself he believed in all of that. I guess this is part of his evolution, of how he goes from obeying orders to standing for what he thinks is really right, but it still came off as shaky.

On the other hand, the story itself was enjoyable, with an original twist about angels and demons. Well, alright, at first I wasn’t sure whether I would’ve wanted those to be closer to their original myths, or not; however, now that I’ve finished the book, it feels like a positive aspect, that provides a nice change from more classical retellings of such fights. It’s a good thing that there is no God here to steer the ship; we are presented with people who, all in all, are still human, or at least evolved from humans, and as such, who are prone to mistakes (but then, there’s the black snake… will more be revealed about its role later on?). The ending of this first novel leaves several doors open, regarding various possibilities of action for the characters; I feel like it doesn’t have to end in a full-blown war… yet it could just as well… or there could be yet another path to follow. At this point, the outcome is not predictable, and I like that.

What I appreciated most was that there was more than met the eye to the two sides of the war. The angels whom everyone expects to be ‘pure’ and ‘good’ actually have their lot of bastards, double-standards, lies and downright crass goals; while the demons, supposedly evil and dark, probably have their lot of ambiguous characters and darker aims as well (I don’t know what’s going to be tackled in the two other novels, after all), yet were clearly not the totally bad guys they were made to look like. In fact, the character I liked the most throughout the whole novel was Chris, and I hope we get to see more of him in book 2! Even Jonas had a nice side to him, in spite of not being shown under the best light in the world.

Although I’m not giving full marks to this novel, I am positive that its setting and story have strong bases, and that the author’s next works can only evolve in an even better direction. (See my review of The Moon Dwellers for more David Estes.)